Pizza Stone Turned Black? Tips for Cleaning and Restoring to Original Color

We all agree that we love pizza, right? Some of you might even enjoy making pizza. But, what we might not enjoy is the part that comes after making and eating pizza; cleaning the kitchen.

Owning a pizza stone is one way to show that you take your baking quite seriously, but knowing how to clean it is a skill on its own. Many trials and errors with conventional home ovens would quickly reveal to you that using a pizza stone is the best way to get the perfect pizza crust. Luckily, your pizza stone can be put to good use in the kitchen in making a variety of other foods, but expect the wear and tear that comes with age.

Can You Clean A Burnt Pizza Stone?

Yes, you can clean a burnt pizza stone. A pizza stone turned black might be unsightly, but don’t completely write it off yet. A few cleaning materials, the right amount of patience, and meticulousness will have your pizza stone looking good as new. To get longevity out of your pizza stone, clean it after every use or two.

Pizza Stone Turned Black? Here’s How to Clean it Correctly

Pizza stones – or baking stones, come in different sizes and can be made from steel, stone, ceramic, or clay. The more frequently you use your pizza stone, the darker it becomes. And as your stone darkens, it loses its non-stick quality.

  • To clean your darkened pizza stone, your stone must first be completely cool. A hot stone could get damaged coming into contact with water. 
  • Now, wet the stone with a small amount of water.
  • If there are chunks of food stuck on the surface and in the crevices of your stone, scrape them off using a blunt knife or spatula. Brush off any other crumbs or leftover particles with a pizza stone brush. If you don’t have a pizza stone brush, you can substitute it with a stainless steel brush.
  • Once you have gotten all the chunks off your pizza stone, wipe the surface of the stone with a damp cloth. Allow your pizza stone to air dry.

NOTE: Some people recommend washing your pizza stone in the dishwasher, but that might not be the best idea seeing as most stones are not dishwasher-friendly. A quick spin in the dishwasher would give you a cleaner pizza stone, but we do not recommend it.

What materials can help you get the black off a pizza stone?

The first thing to know before cleaning your pizza stone is this; do not clean it with soap or you will have the residue in your stone for a long time. Have these tools handy instead:

  • Blunt knife
  • Pizza stone brush
  • Water
  • Spatula
  • Cloth
  • Stainless steel brush
  • Baking soda

Make a baking soda paste with one part water and three parts baking soda. After cooling and scraping your pizza stone, apply your baking soda mixture and scrub gently with a brush. Wipe off the paste with a cloth, and if you still have some stubborn bits stuck to your pizza stone, it’s time to fire up the big guns.

Place your stone in the oven and heat up to 500℉. Leave the stone to heat up for between 15 – 60 minutes.

Read also: Raw Chicken in The Fridge for Three Days? Here’s What Happens

How do you know if a Pizza Stone is bad?

A pizza stone turned black might look unsightly, but a change in color doesn’t mean it’s time to toss it out. In fact, pizza stone blackening over time is quite natural. If you feel like your pizza stone turned black too quickly, a routine cleaning will fix it.

Most pizza stones are versatile and will last several years with good maintenance. But while you can expect your trusty kitchen tool to live long and serve you for many years, your stone can develop some wear and tear over time.

Watch out for cracks in your stone, and avoid strong-smelling foods since they absorb into the stone over time. if you have a cracked pizza stone, your best option is to get a replacement since the damaged stone will simply not perform the same.

Should you wash a pizza stone with soap?

Never clean your pizza stone with soap. Manufacturers don’t advise it, chefs don’t advise it, and we don’t advise it. Pizza stones absorb liquid and will trap some of that soap inside their crevices. What this means is “soap-flavored pizza” for you if you wash your stone with soap.

Our guide to washing your blackened pizza stone should get rid of any stubborn particles on your stone.

Read also: How to Use A Pizza Stone for The First Time

Can I use Bar Keepers Friend on a pizza stone?

You notice your pizza stone turned black and it is rather unsightly. What do you do? Clean it out, of course. You might be tempted to reach out for a can of your trusty cleaning agent; Bar Keepers Friend, but don’t.

Pizza stones do not need to be cleaned with soap or any other cleaning agents. Deep cleaning with water and baking soda will do the trick.

In summary, don’t worry about what to do if your pizza stone turned black over time; it is completely natural. If your stone will be putting in a lot of work baking more than just pizza for you, you should schedule a deep-cleaning after every use or two.

Cleaning a pizza stone is easy with the right materials – water, a soft cloth, baking soda, and a blunt knife. Avoid using oils or soap as soap tends to be absorbed by the stone and may leave a lingering smell.

Pizza stones are a perfect addition to every kitchen, helping you create pizzas to your taste and style. With practice, your pizzas would soon be comparable to pies made from your favorite pizza store.

And finally, replace your pizza stone when it develops too many cracks. But with proper maintenance, you can expect your pizza stone to serve you for many years.